Who She Was
Born Alice Eva Snell in 1867, she was the youngest daughter of Amos Jerome Snell — Chicago's most powerful real estate millionaire and toll-road tycoon. Growing up in his sprawling Washington Boulevard mansion, Alice was raised in the highest tier of Gilded Age society, surrounded by wealth, influence, and the social expectations that came with it.
Beauty & Talent
As a young woman, Alice was one of Chicago's acknowledged beauties, considered by many in New York to have been the most beautiful woman ever sent from the west to the east. Artists raved about her beauty and clamored for the privilege to paint her. She was also a woman of talent — her sketches with brush and pen were greatly admired and her voice, an exceptional soprano, had been carefully trained in Europe. She wrote a song called Autone (Springtime) and a book entitled From London to Paris in a Two-Wheeler.
The true public uproar began immediately after Alice's divorce when she fell in love with Douglass Green, a prominent New York brokerage firm executive. On February 3, 1890, Alice and Douglass eloped in Hampton, Virginia — but the ceremony concealed a devastating secret: Green was still legally married to his first wife and was the father of two children.
Bigamy
While Alice was legally divorced, Douglass Green remained married to his first wife at the time of their secret ceremony. His first wife promptly sued for divorce once the elopement became public.
The Minister Controversy
To keep the ceremony hidden, they were married in secret by a Black minister — an act that deeply shocked racist Victorian-era high society and fueled intense media speculation across the country.
Social Ruin & Exile
Once the secret wedding made front-page news, Green was forced to resign from his prestigious corporate position. The scandalized couple fled to Europe to escape the relentless press.
When Alice and Douglass finally returned from Europe in June 1891, they found themselves completely blacklisted and ostracized by the social elite. Attempting to legitimize their relationship after Green's first wife finalized her divorce, the couple held a second, legal wedding ceremony on June 4, 1891, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The continuous public scrutiny and personal turmoil took a heavy toll on Alice.
She died Mrs. Douglas Green
Alice Snell McCrea Green died on November 7, 1898 in New York City, aged 31. Her obituaries ran under the name Mrs. Douglas Green. She is buried at Rosehill Cemetery, Chicago. Her daughter Henriette went on to become a celebrated translator and theater critic; her son William remained in the custody of Wiley McCrea.
Obituary · Appleton Post, November 17, 1898
"The death of Mrs. Douglas Green, which occurred in the New York Hospital Sunday night from the effects of an operation, recalls a most sensational episode in the social history of the resort known as Old Point Comfort."